← BlogCoaching BusinessNovember 14, 20265 min read

Coaches, Not Creators: What a Coaching App's Business Model Tells You

A coaching app revenue share pitch tells you who the platform really serves. Questions to ask, and why keto and carnivore coaches should care.

Coach Bronson front squatting in a gym, with the MetabolicHQ food diary and coach nutrition screens beside him.

A coach friend forwarded me two pitches this week, from two different software companies. The first was an app backed by a fitness celebrity, marketed to big "creators," free to use, with the platform taking a share of the revenue. The second was a cold message from a co-founder offering to help her "generate recurring monthly revenue" with leaderboards, streaks and rewards, "while you earn recurring income through subscriptions."

Both pitches led with money. Neither one asked a single question about her clients.

That's not a scandal. Software companies need revenue, and so do coaches. But a coaching app revenue share model, and a pitch built around it, tells you exactly who the platform thinks its customer is. It's worth knowing before you hand over your clients.

Why most of us got into this

Especially in the keto and carnivore space, most coaches I know didn't start because it looked like a good business. They started because it changed their own lives. Their energy came back, the joint pain eased, the blood work improved, the training got better instead of harder. Then they wanted to help other people do the same thing.

That's my story too. After 20 years of coaching, changing how I eat changed my recovery, my performance and my quality of life, and it changed what I think coaching is for.

Yes, we want to make money. A coaching business has to be a business, and there's nothing wrong with charging well for work that changes people's lives. The question is what comes first. For coaches like us, the money follows the help. For a lot of platforms, the help is a feature that sells the money.

Creator app vs coaching app

They can look identical in a demo. The difference shows up in what each one is built to grow.

What a coaching app revenue share really costs

"No cost for the app" sounds like a great deal when you're starting out. But a revenue share isn't free. It's a fee that grows every time you do. If a platform keeps even 10% of $6,000 a month in coaching revenue, that's $600 a month, every month, for as long as you're there, and more as you grow.

The bigger cost is incentive. When a platform's income depends on your sales, its roadmap follows your sales: more ways to sell, upsell and keep people subscribed. Features that help a client sleep better, recover better or understand their blood sugar don't move that number, so they wait.

Questions to ask any coaching software company

  1. How do you make money? A flat fee, per client, per coach, or a cut of my revenue?
  2. Who is your customer? Coaches with clients, or creators with audiences?
  3. Do you take a cut of what my clients pay me?
  4. Can I export my clients' data and my programs, any time, and leave?
  5. When I send a feature request, who answers, and do I hear back?
  6. What does your engagement feature reward? Health and consistency, or activity and screen time?
  7. Is it built for how I coach? For us, that means macros instead of calories, and glucose, ketones and recovery, not just a weigh-in.

The answers tell you more than the demo does.

How MetabolicHQ is built

I built MetabolicHQ because I spent years paying software companies that didn't answer, didn't listen and didn't tell me what was going on. So it's set up to answer those questions the right way.

It's free for up to 5 clients, then a flat monthly fee, month to month. That's how it should work when the goal is helping you coach well, not just helping you sell.

Make money by helping people

There's nothing wrong with building a profitable coaching business. Just make sure the software underneath it wants the same thing you do: clients who are healthier, stronger and living better because they worked with you. The revenue takes care of itself when that comes first.

Coach Bronson

Coach BronsonFounder of MetabolicHQ. 20 years coaching human performance and nutrition, 25 in IT engineering and program management. More about me

Try it with your own clients

MetabolicHQ is free for up to 5 clients: training, low-carb nutrition, biometrics and coaching calls in one app under your brand.

Start free